← Back to review dashboard
Prestige — QA Report
# Shopify Prestige Recreation — Final QA Report
**QA date:** 2026-10-24
**Technical status:** COMPLETE — declared local acceptance checks pass
**Visual approval:** PENDING Frederick's review
**Scope:** Public, unaffiliated technical demonstration for website design study and client review
## 1. Reference records
- Shopify Prestige theme listing: https://themes.shopify.com/themes/prestige
- Selected actual storefront reference: https://missionworkshop.com/
- Representative secondary page: https://missionworkshop.com/products/mission-saddle-bag
- Reference capture viewports: `1440×900` and `390×844`
- Intermediate responsive checks: `768px` and `1024px`
The Shopify listing resolved to a preset/theme page rather than one unique storefront. Mission Workshop was selected as the concrete Prestige-style storefront reference. This report does not claim unsupported theme provenance for Mission Workshop.
## 2. Deliverables
### Reference screenshots
- `reference-screenshots/desktop-1440x900.png`
- `reference-screenshots/mobile-390x844.png`
- `reference-screenshots/product-desktop-1440x900.png`
- `reference-screenshots/product-mobile-390x844.png`
### Independent local implementation
- `index.html` — homepage recreation
- `product.html` — representative product-page recreation
- `styles.css` — independent responsive layout and design system
- `app.js` — local-only interaction behavior
- `assets/` — independently sourced substitute imagery
- `ASSET_PROVENANCE.md` — asset and rights record
### Local evidence
- `local-screenshots/home-desktop-1440x900.png`
- `local-screenshots/home-mobile-390x844.png`
- `local-screenshots/product-desktop-1440x900.png`
- `local-screenshots/product-mobile-390x844.png`
- `local-screenshots/home-full-desktop.png`
- `local-screenshots/home-full-mobile.png`
- `local-screenshots/product-full-desktop.png`
- `local-screenshots/product-full-mobile.png`
- `local-layout-qa.json`
### Comparison evidence
- `qa/prestige-comparison-overview.png`
- `qa/homepage-desktop-side-by-side.png`
- `qa/homepage-mobile-side-by-side.png`
- `qa/product-desktop-side-by-side.png`
- `qa/product-mobile-side-by-side.png`
- `qa/homepage-desktop-difference.png`
- `qa/homepage-mobile-difference.png`
- `qa/product-desktop-difference.png`
- `qa/product-mobile-difference.png`
Difference images are visual evidence only. A pixel-difference score would be misleading because the reference photography and logo were intentionally not copied.
## 3. Measured layout results
The browser QA runner verified the captured fixed-viewport layouts and interactions against the independently implemented demonstration.
### Homepage
| Check | Reference observation | Local measured result | Result |
|---|---:|---:|---|
| Desktop viewport | 1440×900 | 1440×900 | PASS |
| Desktop header | 1440×87 | 1440×87 | PASS |
| Desktop first hero section | 810px high | 810px high | PASS |
| Mobile viewport | 390×844 | 390×844 | PASS |
| Mobile header | 390×70 | 390×70 | PASS |
| Mobile hero/next-section transition | approximately y=693 | y=693 | PASS |
| Horizontal overflow | none observed | `scrollWidth == innerWidth` | PASS |
### Product page
| Check | Reference observation | Local measured result | Result |
|---|---:|---:|---|
| Desktop header | 1440×87 | 1440×87 | PASS |
| Desktop product H1 | approximately x=760, y=135 | x=760, y=135 | PASS |
| Desktop gallery stage | image area begins near x=48, y=135 | x=48, y=135, 632×765 | PASS |
| Mobile header | 390×70 | 390×70 | PASS |
| Mobile gallery stage | image region ends near y=590 | x=0, y=70, 390×520, ends y=590 | PASS |
| Mobile product H1 | reference observed near y=620 | x=20, y=625 | PASS with 5px vertical variance |
| Horizontal overflow | none observed | `scrollWidth == innerWidth` | PASS |
### Intermediate widths
- `768px` homepage: no horizontal overflow; mobile header treatment active.
- `768px` product page: no horizontal overflow; gallery is `768×520` and H1 begins at `x=20, y=625`.
- `1024px` homepage: no horizontal overflow; desktop header treatment active.
- `1024px` product page: no horizontal overflow; H1 remains one line after the intermediate-width typography adjustment.
## 4. Interaction results
| Interaction | Result |
|---|---|
| Homepage → product page link | PASS; browser reached `/product.html` and rendered `MISSION SADDLE BAG` |
| Mobile navigation menu | PASS; hidden by default, opens with `display:grid`, sets `aria-expanded=true`, no overflow |
| Search overlay | PASS; opens visibly and closes through the close control |
| Product gallery next control | PASS; image source changed from `assets/bag-product.jpg` to `assets/bag-product-alt.jpg` |
| Product color swatch | PASS; selected color changed to `Olive VX` |
| Quantity control | PASS; quantity incremented from 1 to 2 |
| Local bag drawer | PASS; opened with one line item and displayed count 2 |
| Checkout | Intentionally non-transactional demo alert; no payment or customer data is collected |
## 5. Layout accuracy versus asset/branding differences
### Layout and system elements reproduced
- 87px desktop header and 70px mobile header rhythm.
- Centered header wordmark treatment, desktop navigation and utility controls.
- Mobile hamburger navigation behavior.
- Full-bleed image-led hero with centered eyebrow, title and bordered CTA.
- Light editorial transition section below the hero.
- Image/copy split sections and alternating editorial composition.
- Product page two-column desktop structure.
- Product page full-width mobile gallery followed by product information.
- Gallery arrows, thumbnails, color swatches, quantity control and add-to-cart structure.
- Fixed language control and local drawer/search interaction patterns.
- Homepage section sequence corresponding to the observed reference labels, including Meridian LS, Cache, F/W 2026, Rhake LS, Camera Core Collection, Gradient 2.0, Meridian and Manifest : X51.
### Authorized/documented differences
- Original Mission Workshop photography was not copied. The local build uses independently sourced Unsplash alternatives documented in `ASSET_PROVENANCE.md`.
- The original Mission Workshop logo was not copied. The local build uses an independently written typographic `MW` mark.
- Exact product photography, image composition and product colors therefore cannot be pixel-identical.
- Copy and commerce behavior are local demonstration content. No live checkout, account authentication, order processing or external commerce connection exists.
- Some original live-site motion, collection behavior and below-fold commerce details are represented as static local equivalents.
## 6. Remaining defects and review items
1. Exact hero and product imagery differs because proprietary photography was intentionally replaced.
2. The typographic logo substitute is not the original brand mark.
3. The local implementation does not connect to real commerce, accounts, search, inventory or checkout.
4. The mobile product title begins approximately 5px lower than the measured reference observation.
5. Visual approval remains pending human review of the comparison montage; technical QA passing does not imply visual approval.
## 7. Acceptance decision
**Technical acceptance: PASS.** The local homepage and representative product page render at the required viewports, the fixed-view captures exist, full-page local captures exist, intermediate widths were checked, no horizontal overflow was detected, and the declared local interactions were exercised.
**Visual approval: PENDING.** The comparison montage and difference evidence must be reviewed by Frederick. The intentional asset and branding substitutions are the principal remaining source of visible image-level difference.
## 8. Public demonstration
Open the public homepage at `https://webdesigns.honestfred.com/prestige/`.
`https://webdesigns.honestfred.com/prestige/index.html`
Product page:
`https://webdesigns.honestfred.com/prestige/product.html`